In an unforgettable love story, a woman's impossible journey through the ages could change everything Anne Gallagher grew up enchanted by her grandfather's stories of Ireland. Amy Harmon is a Wall Street Journal, USA Today, and New York Times Bestselling author. What the Wind Knows Summary & Study Guide includes comprehensive information and analysis to Indeed, I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees it this way. Thank you so much for the recap! And if the case hasn't been resolved by June 30 . Maybe you can pretend her long hair is a wig, LOL. Five minutes before the ending: WHAT!? Why did he have to go stab Soo? I think I was really happy while I was alive, Young remarks, which doesnt seem to make a lot of sense. She takes Soos face in her hands as she adds that she has more to tell him, but itll wait until after her surgery. // Load the SDK asynchronously I enjoyed this drama and was mesmerized by it, but at the end of the day, it won't go on my masterpiece or rewatch list. If Soo survived the knifing old baddie would had everyone killed. The blurry images say no. Michael and his men discover the door has been locked and they would have died if not for Anne's warning. I would've found them to be highly problematic in any case, but the fact that that this was a Noh Hee Kyung drama deepened my disappointment exponentially. Hee-sun mentions that theyre going to see Soo tomorrow, but it doesnt seem like theyre seeing him alive when they talk about what flowers to take. Please try again. It was a pleasure reading them. You got your money, whats wrong with you? Tied to her bed and with the shadowy entity looming high, Lizzy stabs Isaac when he tries to stop her from untying herself. Also, Heads! Perhaps instead of questioning whether Lizzy's experiences were real or imagined, the film is trying to suggest that both things can be true at once. And throughout the proceedings of the film, we see a woman's descent into madness. I crack up at times while reading her recaps 'cause she's writing about serious moments in such a dry, humorous way. Mistaken for the boys long-missing mother, Anne adopts her identity, convinced the womans disappearance is connected to her own. Anne decides she must be dreaming and settles in to enjoy her time with Eoin. He confronts her about murdering Emma. Young's hair, everyone's fantastic health etc. His care for Anne shows the type of love every woman should aspire to find. I really wanted to like this show, just like I wanted to like Young, and I find them both frustrating and prickly and immensely illogical. I tried to write down all of the questions I still had at the end, but my fingers got tired. And then the scene changes, so that theyre suddenly kissing on on the same path where Young just walked, with Soo wearing the clothes she saw on him when he passed her on the bike. Nice Guy and TWTWB, both the male protagonists were stabbed, but they survived, right? "What the Wind Knows" is less sex heavy, more passionate romance wise, and the plot line is more intense. Summary. I dont want to admit it, but I cant be a better person. OMGAI thanks so much for recapping this, HeadsNo2 n.n I've literally been coming back to Dramabeans every other hour to see if the recap has been posted yet lol (and all my other hours, I've been watching and re-watching, then rewinding and re-rewatching the same 1 scene from episode 8 of "You're the Best, Lee Soon-shin") haha n.n, It seems to me that the writer changes her mind many times regarding many aspects as she wrote the drama. Drama pls! If she stays, she may alter history. If it'd been left with Soo on a bicycle, then I'd have leaned towards him being dead. There's a gangster figure who seemed really mean, but who is actually a bit of a softie. I sometimes miss some of those, and I appreciate when those are pointed out to me. : In the late fifties the cop got into an accident and burned to death, the priests had known what the cop . Just like the one guy says, "Soo was willing to forget pride". , Publication date 4. I also like how she explains things, we get to see her thought process and I am grateful for that. (And you'll realize how much we need one another in order to overcome our internal obstacles.) But the young couple is clearly not a happy one. :). But fine, lets say Ill buy that love cures all, and that she just needed to know that Soo cared. I think the whole flower thing is to amend for stabbing Oh Soo. Well, he already knew he wanted her to stay with him (forever), so why not have her answer then and there? Talk about a quick recovery time. Is he alive or just a figment of her memories? Third, I agree with Ashely above in that Sung's relationship had soured (three suiters?) I like it that some of you are sharing your personal experiences to help us better understand the characters in the drama. Completely agree, Kaye. I mean, if you want to commit suicide, don't you really slit your wrists (BOTH of them) and get in the water for maximum bleeding? I thought Missing You was running amuck with epic logic fails that just reading recaps confused the heck out of me..But to each their own i guess. I see. :) Hope to read more of your future takes on future dramas. I said above, that I hoped for a more straightforward ending bu that I'll take this, too. He acted well but he still not converting me as one of his fans. After they each pull away, Young comforts him: Dont cry. I understand almost perfectly the desperation to trust / love someone, feel that if I can end this life - maybe I'll find peace, feel that selfishness because I always have to do and settle things all by myself. After hearing this, Lizzy shoots and kills Emma. If nothing else, this was an insanely beautiful show, well-scored and well-acted. or I dont buy that this show was making a statement about clinical depression through Young, but I do buy that she had Drama Depression, with all its requisite symptoms of plot convenience. Some of my questions might seem superficial, however I wish things had been made clear for us :-(. Now, I just can't watch JIS without thinking "he did a porn movie" Cause that's what it is. There seems to be no good outcome here for Lizzy. Amy Harmon is a Wall Street Journal, USA Today, and New York Times bestselling author. FB.init({ Also, Jin Sung was actually about to stab Soo a second time, but couldn't bring himself to do it, so he dropped the knife. . But, no matter what flaws this drama has, I have to admit that I do LOVE this drama. Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club thats right for you for free. I really love him. I really wanted to completely love this show and I did especially the the first third of the drama but the show just started going downhill for me in the last three episodes. and then she comes and "finds" him meaning her surgery must not have worked out and she died. The poet says that the wind makes a mockery of . I think she managed them well on most of the episodes, so kudos to her. I still can't figure out how Mr. Kim killing his family meant that he needed to stab Soo. I think it was the best one we could get. There are no amount of words to describe this book. If it was sooner rather than so close to the end, it would have sat in place better, narratively. Sometimes you can't explain your heart. I didn't think about it that way when watching the final scene so i believed they both died. So is she over the suicide thing? What we dont know is whether Lizzy was in her senses when she committed the murder. This ambiguous ending reminds me of "Ironweed" by William Kennedy. Song Hye Gyo also said in the interview that the ending scene filmed in Young's perspective was blurry because they didn't want to give RP patients false hope, since those diagnosed with RP will not ever regain back their sight fully. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Explained of The Wind Rises. It was amazing because it is not really easy to write an open ended story and with so much twists. Her fantasy novel, THE BIRD AND THE SWORD was a Goodreads Best Book finalist. It put a different edge on the thoughts of the Irish problems in 1918 and 1921/22 because the people of Ireland loved their country so much but at the same time it became complicated. "I highlighted line after line within these pages, again completely awe-struck as I read feelings and thoughts I have experienced, but have never been able to put into words as eloquently as Amy Harmon. Here's who won, and what it means for the future of the MonsterVerse. Could you please make sense? But in the end, it became just another k-melo that lost its footing, yet garnered tons of attention anyway. It was, however, executed very poorly imo. js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; And when he turns around he gets stabbed. As Leaphorn, Chee, and Manuelito converged on the thieves' cave, they. You could drive a truck through them. During this period, many families moved from populated urban centers in the east to the vastly underpopulated western plains. The cinematography was imo not distracting but rather very well intergrated and instrumetalized, the music was good (this is where i usually loose my patience first) and Jo In Sung and Song Hye Gyo just clicked for melike massively, hugely, "pleaaase work together again". I was captivated.. Drummond takes up the Bible in one hand, Darwin's The Origin of Species in the other, balancing the two books. One evening, Anne, Thomas, and Michael are at a gathering at the Gresham Hotel when Anne suddenly remembers reading about a tragedy that took place at that hotel. Like what were they trying to achieve with that effect? As for the ending, I still kinda feel in some way that Soo is actually dead and whatever was happening was happening in some parallel universe, lol. He was not quite ready hence she couldn't see him until he was. Politics and peril in The Secret Romantic Guesthouse, You can only pick one: Friends-to-lovers drama, First script reading for tvN's Stealer: Seven Joseon Coins. What the Wind Knows takes this idea and expands upon in it, layer upon beautiful layer. Fans of Outlander will treasure this book. Olivia Hawker, author of The Ragged Edge of Night, With masterful and enchanting storytelling, Amy Harmon weaves a tale of epic love, alternating between the present and war-torn Ireland in 1921 like a seasoned historian. What's Up With the Ending? As far as stabbing goes guns are really hard to get in Korea so stabbing's the best way to kill someone. window.fbAsyncInit = function() { Initially shown to be self-sufficient and capable of warding off wolves, Lizzy has suffered whenever we see her left alone. I love reading your insightful, witty and humorous recaps. They could have done the movie with only half of them. It is what it is. Her great-grandfather lived in this part of Ireland, and the landscape spoke to her, compelling her to write a story set in his time. Please try your request again later. Granted, I'm not familiar with Irish history, making everything in these pages new to me. Oh, and yes, thanks to TWTB, I also discovered Jo In Sung!! Had Soo survived, there was no way, the gangster boss, Kim, would have let Jingsung lived happily. Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them. He might cook too, but I didn't strike me as anything fancy. How will Gangster Kim overlook a non dead Soo. All three were markers of humanity, of time, of life. It means that humans have decided to live, even though we keep expanding without limits, and producing pollution. A big DITTO to what you said. It was also hard to express it as clearly and well-argued as you have done here. Ivoire, I am late to this but what is it with will-he-die melos of late and their nonsensical endings? =), We actually see the flowers Hee-sun talked about on the table, so they were for our Soo. Was this technique not used by both Soo and Young more than a few times throughout the drama? I was also unhappy that Soo didn't take the money, making his con a moot point but whatever. My words are inadequate, but I hope they will encourage readers to pick this book up and stick with the story throughout. I also think that they wouldn't have shown the "Next Spring" title if it was meant to be a dream or heaven. When that time comes, you will answer all of my questions without hiding anything. I salute the writer as well as Ju in sung and Oh young very well-acted characters. The first eight episodes were executed close to perfection imo but I didn't really mind the change in pace afterwards. var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; (and really, if it's a happy ending, is it so hard to just give us a straight forward ending but why also a stabby scene? I don't know. What the Wind Knows by Amy Harmon. With the help of an FBI officer (Jane Banner) and locals alike, the two try to uncover what seems to be a mysterious murder. The vast open spaces, combined with the lack of commercial construction, resulted in small households living alone on huge tracts of land. Thomas, Eoin's guardian, is wealthy for the time and place, and he is a supporter of the Irish fight for independence. Really? Like Heads said, there are other ways to say you miss someone. I waited for you for a long time, Young says. Whether it really hurt you as much as it hurt me when you were lying. JS to me was a consistent character. But he had some charisma so that got brushed away at the end. No payoff with Denna Ambrose The secret in the Archives his music career the Chandrian his university studies with Fella With sympathy or naming. This article contains Eternals spoilers.. Eternals is a big movie for Marvelin every sense of the word.. But seriously, despite its at times heavy flaws- I still love the show. Lizzys tale is pieced together through time jumps, simultaneously exploring her sinister past and rapidly deteriorating present. Which means Soo can play against him and take all he has left. Thank you again Heads for being on this journey with us and for helping us make sense of it. I was also wondering, why shouldn't have JS hanged up on HS? Secretary Wang wants to know why, considering how she made Young, you know, blind. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. And I do wonder if everyone really takes the time to read all comments or just stay firm in their opinions no matter what? Wow. To me it appeared a cop out or a compromise how ever you want to go. The physical dangers were numerous, but in the 2018 horror film "The Wind" (which was added to Netflix in June), it's the psychological terrors that take focus. I can see just enough to see that youre very good looking, she adds. It speaks of the ordinary and the extraordinary events and people that are entwined in a way that captures the very essence of Ireland during this period. Thank you for the recommendation - watched it, like it! !and more importantly they are both happy. Required fields are marked *. hahaha, priceless. "NHK lost her soul to the devil". A wonderful, glorious and heartfelt story! Even at the moment when I wanted to end it, a part of me still wanted you to run back to me. In the case of Deus, the system knows Lily should behave one way based on all the rules of determinism. A call to Hee-sun affirms that Boss Man isnt lying, and Jin-sung looks devastated as the mean old geezer slides him a knife. What would be the point of having that conversation of how Soo told Wang to not tell Young about his whereabouts until she was done chemo? ..Show you have less than 10 minutes to make him reincarnate. So in a sense, this ending was a miracle painted in the most idealistic way possible. Wang walking back in so easily into OY's life. I really liked the beginning (episode 8 was definitely the climax of happiness for me) but then we dove into melo land which culminated in a LOT of crying in the last episode. She got the call from Jin-sung while she was on her way to treat Young. Thank you. From what we can tell, Lizzy and Isaac were part of a wave of settlers along the Western frontier of the United States during the 1800s. : *cries*. I wait patiently for the show and the recap for every episode. Even if she survives the stab wound from the scissors, which is bleeding profusely, she most likely slowly descends into madness before long. I cant forgive you, she says. Or something? It is interesting to note that the only person that we see interacting with the reverend is Lizzy. As folks already pointed out, I just don't get why Sec. Oh soo waited for Oh young to recover (6 months). }(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk')); Please enter your username or email address. Late in the narrative, Isaac finds the diary in Lizzy's possession, which prompts him to realize that Lizzy likely had something to do with Emma's death. I think that is what the writer ment. Apparently shes been a regular at his restaurant and picked up on the sound of his bracelet, and though hed always bring her tea he never showed his face to her. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness. But in true drama fashion, we know Soos cards must be the winning ones, and Jin-sung knows as well since Soo just leaves him there. In the meantime, Young gets wheeled in for surgery. Kristoffer Rus's feature debut Into the Wind is the kind of young-adult romance that seems to have been written by throwing darts at a board full of cookie-cutter plot elements and character backstories, making it a predictable endeavor, to put things mildly. Directed by Kristoffer Rus in the director's feature debut, the Polish-original teen romantic comedy travel movie 'Into the Wind' ('Pod Wiatr') is a fantastic and subtle love story that doubles as a coming-of-age of the female protagonist. But to me what he did made sense for the character. Maybe he felt like a cornered mouse or panicked. These flowers symbolize happines, wedding, and love. Link's Awakening might not be as plot-heavy and narrative-driven as say a game like Breath of the Wild, but there are still some deep plot elements that make this game as memorable as anything else. The Final Night (Edie and Dawn) What Remains of Edith Finch - Story and Ending Explained. I glossed over a lot of the things a lot of people struggled with eg. Cant we get some blunt force trauma up in here to change things up? So it kinda kills me to read HeadsNo2's criticisms (that I agree with, btw) about often not being able to understand Young and other characters in this drama. Thank you all, and thank you HeadsNo2 for your recaps. Notes from the translator. I cant even. There is absolutely no reason to vague up a happy ending so yeah that was not a happy ever after ending. With stunning visuals, the film manages to make one feel close to the sea. Flowers were for the grave. And I read and understood the part about OS wanting Boss Man to join in the game so OS can gamble against him and win his money. :). We also see scenes from Emmas pregnancy, during which she is similarly tormented by a faceless spirit. Its magical, atmospheric, and compelling, a book that will haunt you for a long time. Rhys Bowen, New York Times and #1 Kindle bestselling author of The Tuscan Child, In Farleigh Field, and the Royal Spyness novels, Amy Harmon brings a tragic and fascinating period of history to life with a poignant love story that plays out across time and oceans. For Vegas and victory. Blurry. 0.0/10 from 0 users. One's Dream Leads To The Deaths Of Thousands The message of this film is clear and simple "beauty is fragile; our lives, our dreams, and our health are mere flickers of time in a weary world." Maybe it was the timing in which it happened. It was a visually lovely show to watch. Agreed. Doing the right thing is often synonymous with doing the difficult thing. Any Way . To me, this drama fizzled out around episode 8. Maybe they are all waiting for Moo chul to show up. The flowers conversation between JS and HS says no. What a delight, to begin the year with one of my most anticipated reads of 2019, by one of my favorite authors of all. When I watched the ending, I was really angry at first, because I felt that I had been totally manipulated to create some sort of artsy-fartsy ambiguous ending, logic, story flow, and characterization be damned. Spencer and Alex have been through so much in their journey from Kenya to (what appears to be) Marseille: lions, venal British colonists . Im going to backtrack a bit to the attempted suicide, frankly because it still doesnt make any godforsaken sense on my end. I always felt as if she was always looking at me with all her body and heart. This final episode left me confused and with a sense of "this was it?" Marvel . It was so slow and we were made to think that OS died, because JS didn't seem to do anything to help him and yet, he didn't gut him a 2nd time, which seems like he wanted him to live. It was only in the last episode where the drama hinted at how he likes to cook. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Boss Man turns over Soos cards, revealing that Soo did have a flush, and thus the winning hand. If the fact that AFF is a story about a sexual relationship between two people growing into something else isn't enough justification for it having sex scenes, I don't know what is. Watching that drama made me want to be sure not to take any of my loved ones for granted, to look for the good in each person, and to sing Kumbaya (just kidding). An Amazon Charts, Wall Street Journal, and Washington Post bestseller. I am not sure I can bothered to understand anything from the last episode. Reviewed in the United States on February 21, 2023. Eoin is a retired doctor who grew up in Ireland, and Anne is a successful author. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the show but I just feel disappointed because it could have been a great drama. I guess there are so many probabilities with this, it's kind of crazy. The bad friends, the conniving fiancee all forgiven and even rewarded, what a message to send to the public. That "happy" ending felt so contrived for me. Now he knows, and knowing is half the battle. The Thing Ending Explained . These 2 things really disappointed me, there were definetely some things who could have been done better, but on the other hand, im sure not many directors/writers could have succeded in making it better or at least as good as these producers did. The game amps up as Jin-sungs family loads the truck to move though theyre being watched by a shady-lookin dude. 2. Having grown up in the middle of wheat fields without a television, with only her books and her siblings to entertain her, she developed a strong sense of what made a good story. Its interesting to note that, apart from possibly being tricked by the evil entity to murder both Emma and Isaac, Lizzy also had real-life motives to cause them harm. She can write characters with extremely logical and complex psyche, even the baddies. Amy Harmon's characters were absolutely believable especially as many genuine historical figures kept appearing in this lovely story which made it truly believable. I got tired of the cons, of the directing, of the music. Highly recommend. Ending the game, we learn that Koholint and the rest of its inhabitants only exist within the Windfish's dream. And even if you were, wouldnt it have been cooler to see that moment of decision instead? So, you never know right! My first reaction to the ending was Soo is dead and all is in Young's head (because I'm a sucker for apparently, the traditional melodrama ending - I've been so out of it, I didn't know open ending or happy ending is an option!). Lawyer Jang finds Secretary Wang in the countryside, where she watches her elderly parents from afar. Cherry blossom petals rain down as they kiss in soft-focus surroundings. One day, Anne chases Eoin's ball into the lough and she begins to fade away. The result is confused audience. I was hopeful in the beginning, because it started with NHK doing her empathy-building magic with Soo's character, and to a lesser extent with Young's character through the video diaries. Sex is a natural part of our life and that is artistically shot and they are just depicting a natural human behavior to get aroused and be lustful, because if you don't then you are not normal . And Jinsung and Hee Sung were talking about the memorial for Soo. Here is the ending of "The Wind" explained. I love happy ending! The show ended with a major loophole. That scene left me really perplexed because I would have liked to have known what happened (considering how long OS seemed to have been on the ground and he seemed dead. She learns that a doctor named Thomas Smith raised Eoin after Eoin's parents died during the revolution. "I must not be crazy, it is not all in my head" I thought. The first part of the poem describes the action of the wind. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions. Her suspicions are confirmed when she finds Emma's diary in her cabin, which details not only her secret relationship with Isaac but also the fact that the baby Emma was carrying may have been his and not her husband's. Soo stays vigilant at Youngs bedside until she wakes and realizes hes there with her. It didn't disgust me though. I guess they do look like people and act like people then. May 20, 2021; yats chipotle alexio recipe; workplace accident prevention strategies . This is a drama that maybe forgets the title. "What the Wind Knows" is less sex heavy, more passionate romance wise, and the plot line is more intense. I'm in dramaland and i want the happy ending of course. Scene 1 Jin sung tells Boss Man that all the winnings are his in order to pay Soo's debt, but Boss Man has another plan - he knows where Jin sung's family is, threatening Jin Sung to choose between Soo or his family. But the wind throws the books and tears the pages. Eventually, he accepts that she is able to predict the future with uncanny accuracy. The film's final act balances shocking reveals and enigmatic quandariesthat will have even the most astute viewers questioning what is real. Seriously. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. It's by no means the worst thing I've ever seen, but it was a letdown - I can live with Young's suicide attempt, but the sudden Drama Fairy handwaving of it is too much. But gradually, the characters grew on me, and their relationships touched me. It was blurry because it was trying to show it in Young's perspective. But that's really the only thing I wonder. but I wondered if it would be rude in a way or something. Im glad he grew as a person, but since when did Growth = Passivity? In the end, the suicide attempt didnt even put her out for a night, and she was completely fine by morning. Poor guys had better days. }); She considers trying to return to Thomas and the young Eoin, but she can never replicate the conditions. Redemption links and eBooks cannot be resold. I loved how Kim Bum's character broke out of his loyalty and had that crazed, red rimmed look after he stabbed Oh Soobut then..wha.? fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); The one glaring weakness, for me, was the whole Jin-sung stabs Soo scene. The ending was open ended. 3. I sooooooo appreciate that. Only our relationships, our legacies of love, and the stories of our passions will be the things that matter in the end.I don't know where to begin in describing my admiration for the characters. My biggest gripe is the directing of this show. Lawyer Jang tries to get Soo to take the money on Youngs behalf, since it would make her feel better. Kindle AZW file. I am confused about a number of things in this episode (trust me on that one) and I am still writing (what looks like it will be my somewhat long) response. The Wind is an American Supernatural film that follows elements of horror and mystery in the Wild West. There's profuse amounts of sex and nudity, some violence and the emphasis is on tone and emotion over plot and specific coherence. It was written with such depth and heartfelt feeling and I became so involved in the lives of Eoin, Anne and Thomas and many others too. This is going to be in my all time fav list. : I do agree with you that how we got to that light at the end of the tunnel was more important than the light itself. He was always morally flexible as were most of these characters. This Study Guide consists of approximately 65pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - Oh and I forgot to add. I can accept this ending though I wished for a happier one. Why is everything so blurry?
